It doesn't make you evil, I think it makes you incredibly brave. I myself am not a Christian (Pagan by choice since I was about 13), but my best and dearest friend is and he is gay. He often gets frustrated by people who are blinded by their own prejudices and start painting others with the same brush...

From my point of view, people who leave comments like the one you opened with, are not at all a part of the solution. Hypocrites of the highest order; touting tolerance and understanding and refusing to lead by example.

*hugs*